GivFlow vs. MortarStone
Short answer: MortarStone and GivFlow both start from your church's giving data, but they do different jobs. MortarStone focuses on giving analytics, budget forecasting and coaching. GivFlow does the follow-up: it notices failed gifts, new and lapsed donors, recurring opportunities and pledges, sends the right note from your church, and shows what came back.
We publish GivFlow, so read this with that in mind. What we say about MortarStone comes from mortarstone.com and its listing in Planning Center's integration directory, checked on November 9, 2026. If something has changed, tell us and we'll fix it.
Who each one is best for
MortarStone is a good fit if
- You want deep giving analytics: retention, top and core givers, benchmarks, giving scores and dozens of reports.
- You want help building and forecasting the annual budget.
- You'd like a coach or advisor to help build a generosity strategy.
- Your church uses a church management or giving system that GivFlow doesn't connect to yet.
GivFlow is a good fit if
- Your church gives through Planning Center and your staff doesn't have time to act on what the reports show.
- You want failed card and ACH gifts followed up automatically, from your church's address, until the gift comes back.
- You want one-time givers invited to give monthly, new and second gifts thanked, and lapsed givers checked on, without building lists every week.
- You run pledge campaigns and want a pledge form that already knows each donor, plus follow-up through fulfillment.
Side-by-side, as of Nov 2026
From each company's public site. Where MortarStone's site doesn't describe something, we say so rather than guess.
| Criteria | GivFlow | MortarStone |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Automated donor follow-up and pledge campaigns, with tracked outcomes | Giving analytics, budget management and forecasting, coaching |
| Failed gift follow-up | Multi-step sequence for card and ACH from your church's domain; recovered gifts are tracked | Not described on its site |
| Donor emails | Flows for new, second gift, active to recurring, failed, lapsed, recovered and dormant donors; each flow stops when the donor acts | "Automated Email Engagement" and "Reach New & Inactive Givers" listed on its plans page |
| Pledge campaigns | Personalized pledge form and links, One Fund and Traditional, follow-up through fulfillment | Campaign tracking and pledge progress reports |
| Budgets and forecasting | Budgets are fund and campus groups with their own donor statuses; no budget forecasting | Annual budget planning and a 12-month giving forecast |
| Coaching | Personal onboarding and support; no coaching program | Dedicated coach and quarterly advisor sessions (Coaching track and Guide Service) |
| Planning Center | Reads giving and writes donor status, donation status and tiers back to a GivFlow tab in Planning Center nightly | Pulls giving data from Planning Center nightly, per its Planning Center listing |
| Other platforms | Planning Center today | Lists many systems, including Pushpay, Rock RMS, Subsplash, Breeze and MinistryPlatform |
| Pricing | Published on the site, no call needed: $49 to $319/mo by donation volume, custom above 5,000; every feature on every plan. See pricing | Free Basic Track. Paid tracks (Growth and Coaching) show no price on the plans page; you get a price by talking with their team |
On pricing: you can see exactly what GivFlow costs on our pricing page, no call needed. MortarStone's Basic Track is free, and its paid tracks don't list a price, so you'd get one on a call with their team.
The real difference: reports vs. follow-up
A report can tell you a recurring gift failed or a faithful giver went quiet. Someone still has to reach out. In most churches that someone is already stretched, so the list gets looked at and the emails don't go out.
GivFlow is built for that gap. Your team approves the wording once. GivFlow notices the moment, sends the note from your church, stops when the donor acts, and reports what came back. Replies go to the person you choose.
What that looked like for two churches:
- Failed gifts. At Bayside Community Church, follow-up recovered 64% of failed card gifts and 67% of failed ACH gifts, compared with 24% without it. Read the Bayside story.
- Pledges. First UMC Murfreesboro went from 212 pledges ($1,804,464) to 300 pledges ($2,128,196) with GivFlow pledge campaigns. Read the First UMC story.
GivFlow has served churches since 2020 and works with 300+ churches today, with $1.8M+ in recovered and added giving over the last 12 months.
Use both, or switch
This doesn't have to be either/or. Some churches keep an analytics tool for board reports and forecasting and add GivFlow for the follow-up. GivFlow connects to your giving platform on its own, so nothing has to move.
If you'd rather run one tool, switching is simple. Connect your giving platform, approve the wording for each flow, and turn them on. Setup takes under 30 minutes, onboarding is personal, there's no long-term contract, and there's a 60-day money-back guarantee once you've set up a flow.
Not sure yet? Start with the free, read-only Giving Audit to see what slipped in your last 3 months of gifts, or book a 30-minute walkthrough.
Frequently asked questions
Is GivFlow a MortarStone alternative?
For some churches, yes. If what you need most is someone, or something, to act on your giving data (recover failed gifts, invite recurring giving, check in on lapsed donors, follow up on pledges), GivFlow does that work for you. If you mainly want deep analytics, budget forecasting and a generosity coach, MortarStone is built for that.
Can we use GivFlow and MortarStone together?
Yes. They do different jobs. MortarStone can stay your reporting and forecasting tool while GivFlow runs the follow-up. GivFlow connects to your giving platform directly, so it doesn't need anything from MortarStone.
Does GivFlow process gifts?
No. GivFlow works alongside the giving platform you already use (Planning Center today). Donors keep giving where they give now. GivFlow sends the follow-up and tracks what happened.
What does GivFlow cost?
Pricing is published and based on donations per month, from $49/mo for up to 250 donations to $319/mo for 5,000, with custom pricing above that. You can see your price on the pricing page without a sales call. Every plan includes every flow and all pledge campaigns. No setup fee, no long-term contract, and a 60-day money-back guarantee.
Which giving platforms does GivFlow work with?
Planning Center Giving and People today. MortarStone lists integrations with many church management and giving systems, so if you are not on Planning Center, it may connect where GivFlow doesn't yet.
How long does it take to switch on GivFlow?
Setup takes under 30 minutes after you connect your giving platform, and onboarding is personal. Your team approves the wording before anything sends.