Church Case Study Failed gift recovery

Bayside covered their GivFlow cost in week one

How a multi-campus Planning Center church turned failed gifts into recovered giving, with almost no staff time.

We immediately saw it working. The first donor not only fixed their recurring gift. They made a manual donation to cover the one that failed. That one donor covered our entire GivFlow cost.

Pastor John Kipp, CFO
Pastor John Kipp, CFO
Bayside Community Church
Week 1
First recovered gift
Cost covered
By one donor's make-up gift
Zero hours
Staff time after setup
Church
Bayside Community Church
Size
Large
Location
Florida, United States
Platform
Planning Center

Like a lot of churches on Planning Center, Bayside Community Church knew some gifts failed. They did not realize how many, or how little came back on its own.

Planning Center sent one failure email. The church was not monitoring the rest. There was no follow-up system. In 2024, 6.9% of Bayside’s gifts failed. Only 24% of those came back without follow-up.

“We were not monitoring it. We didn’t realize the extent of the missed opportunities.”

, Pastor John Kipp, CFO

What they turned on

Bayside connected GivFlow to Planning Center. GivFlow started watching for failed gifts and new donors. When a recurring gift failed, GivFlow sent a gracious, personalized email: what happened, and a simple way to fix it. No pressure, no shame.

They also used budgets to welcome new donors based on giving to multi-campus tithes and offerings and kingdom builders funds.

Week one

Within the first week, a donor got the failed-gift email, fixed their recurring gift, and made a manual donation to cover the one that failed. That one make-up gift covered Bayside’s entire GivFlow cost.

“We immediately saw it working. The first donor not only fixed their recurring gift. They made a manual donation to cover the one that failed. That one donor covered our entire GivFlow cost.”

, Pastor John Kipp, CFO

Results

Without follow-up, about 24% of failed gifts came back. With GivFlow, Bayside recovered 64% of failed card gifts and 67% of ACH, about 2.4× and 2.5× better.

GivFlow did not just lift recovery. It gave Bayside a way to reach new donors early, the donor care they wished they had time for.

“It was easy to see the benefits far outweighed the costs. The first donor to correct their giving and make a manual donation for the failed one covered the cost. GivFlow’s willingness to allow a test period to prove this showed their confidence in the impact that would be there.”

, Pastor John Kipp, CFO

Pastoral care, not just recovery

GivFlow doesn’t just solve a financial problem; it pastorally bridges the gap between generosity intended and generosity completed, serving both the church and the giver with care.

, Pastor John Kipp, CFO, Bayside Community Church

What the team does differently now

Failed gifts are monitored automatically. Donors fix issues without a staff chase. New donors get a welcome that can point to Growth Track and serve opportunities. The team stays on ministry instead of building manual lists.

“We immediately started thinking about additional automations that could help donors. An email to new donors with links to our Growth Track and Serve Opportunities has helped new engagement as well.”

, Pastor John Kipp, CFO

24%
Recovered without follow-up
64%
Card recovery with GivFlow

~2.4× better

67%
ACH recovery with GivFlow

~2.5× better

We don't disclose Bayside's real recovered dollar totals. Every green section of this chart is real dollars GivFlow added back.

Bayside Community Church results with GivFlow

Frequently asked questions

How fast did Bayside see results with GivFlow?

Within the first week. One donor fixed their recurring gift and made a manual donation to cover the failed one. That single make-up gift covered Bayside's entire GivFlow cost.

What recovery rates did Bayside see?

Without follow-up, about 24% of failed gifts came back. With GivFlow, Bayside recovered 64% of failed card gifts and 67% of ACH. In 2024, 6.9% of Bayside's gifts were failing.

Does GivFlow work with Planning Center?

Yes. Bayside connected GivFlow to Planning Center. GivFlow watches for failed gifts and new donors, then sends gracious, personalized emails. No shame, no pressure.

How much staff time does it take after setup?

After setup, Bayside did not need staff hours to chase failed gifts. Donors fix issues from the email. The team stays focused on ministry.

Is this only about recovering dollars?

No. Pastor John Kipp frames it as pastoral care: bridging the gap between generosity intended and generosity completed, for the church and the giver.

Final Thoughts

Who benefits most from GivFlow?

My first reaction is that the church benefits most, and for good reason. GivFlow reduces administrative friction, recovers giving that would otherwise be lost, improves cash-flow reliability, and provides clearer reporting for leaders. But the more I think about it, the more I realize the donor may benefit just as much, if not more. Failed donations can carry embarrassment or hesitation, especially when the gift was prayerfully intended. GivFlow allows us to respond in a gracious, timely way, explaining what happened and showing a simple path to fix it without pressure or shame. In that moment, it honors the donor's spiritual intent and preserves trust.
- Pastor John Kipp, CFO

Book a 30-minute walkthrough and we will show you how it would work with your Planning Center data.